FOOTBALL

• Bill Zelle / 2nd team / 1979
• Steve Willett / 1st team / 1985
• Jim Tully / 2nd team / 1986
• Kevin Wiley / 1st team / 1989
• Nick Butler / 1st team / 1994
• Preston Nicholson / 1st team / 2007
• Andrew Rupcich / 1st team (AFCA-NAIA) / 2nd team (AP NAIA) / 2019
• Andrew Rupcich / 1st team (AFCA-NAIA) / 2020
• Andrew Rupcich / 1st team (AFCA-NAIA) / 2021
• Dalton Huffman 2nd team (AFCA-NAIA) / 2021  

MEN'S BASKETBALL

• Dane Brooks / 3rd team / 2007
• Marshawn Norris / 2nd team / 2013
• James Johnson / 3rd team / 2014

WOMEN'S BASKETBALL

• Carrie Lynn Connell / 1st team / 1993
• Cathy Shoup / 2nd team / 1996

SOFTBALL

• April Stary / 1st team / 1993
• April Stary / 1st team / 1994
• Jessica Leenerts / 1st team / 2001
• Avery Johnson / 2nd team / 2019

TRACK AND FIELD

• Jordan Bucklew / Decathlon (Outdoor) / 2008
• Zach Rosenberger / Pole Vault (Outdoor) / 2008
• Zach Rosenberger / Pole Vault (Indoor) / 2009
• Zach Rosenberger / Pole Vault (Outdoor) / 2009
• Jordan Bundy / Pole Vault (Outdoor) / 2009
• Stefanos Koufidis / Pole Vault (Indoor) / 2010 (NAIA Champion)
• Stefanos Koufidis / Pole Vault (Outdoor) / 2010 (NAIA Champion)
• Jermaine Jones / High Jump (Outdoor) / 2013
• Jermaine Jones / High Jump (Indoor) / 2015
• Jermaine Jones / High Jump (Outdoor) / 2015
• Paige Bray / 200-meter dash (Outdoor) / 2017
• Delaney Strauss / Heptathlon (Outdoor) / 2024  

WOMEN'S VOLLEYBALL

• Kamrin Gold / 3rd team / 2013
• Kamrin Gold / 2nd team / 2014

MEN'S VOLLEYBALL

• Ammuniki Wood / 1st team / 2018

WOMEN'S BOWLING

• Rachel Moore / 1st team / 2024